Directory · Method

How We Check an Operator

Every field on an operator page shows what it says, where that came from and the date we read it. This page explains what each label means and what a Green Fins level tells you.

The three evidence labels, and what each one means

checked means a register or an authority states it. On the dive pages that is Green Fins, and the membership level carries the assessment with it.

claimed means the operator states it, and the source line says where we read the claim: their own website, their agency profile, or a reply to an email. It shows what they claim, not that it's true.

not checked means we couldn't check it. The field stays on the page with this label.

How we read agency names from websites

Picking agency names out of website text by software is easy to get wrong, and a wrong reading means a false statement about a named business. So a name found this way is only a candidate until a person has read the sentence it came from. Until then the directory shows nothing for it. Once we publish the name, we publish that sentence next to it, so you can check our reading yourself. If we couldn't get a whole sentence, the row says so instead of quoting a fragment. That applies to six of 550 readings (more on this below).

Some sentences we rejected. Each one named a training body that the business had not claimed:

A state license is a different kind of evidence from a membership. What an RNAAT licence proves explains what Portugal's register confirms and what it leaves open.

If the best text on a page is a heading, a menu or a price row, the row says so and doesn't quote it. If the sentence is about the instructors rather than the school, the row says that too, because these bodies certify people and affiliate businesses separately. If the text starts in the middle of a sentence, the row shows the agency name but no quote. If we withdraw a reading, the record says which body and why.

Three things worth knowing about the claimed fields

An agency named on an operator's own site is a claim. We couldn't look up the membership: PADI and most other bodies publish no member list we can read, so a logo on the website is as far as we can see. A license number is more useful than a logo, because you can check it with the authority yourself. Instructor languages are what the operator states. Teams change with the season, so a list from last winter may not hold this month.

We start at the website address listed in the register. If an agency is named on that page, that's our reading. If not, we follow up to three links on the same site whose address or wording points to courses, certification, licenses or the team. Plenty of schools name PADI on their courses page but not on the front page, and reading only the front page reported them as naming none.

The Agency column can show three things. An agency name links to the page we found it on, so you can open it yourself. A dash means no agency name was on any page we opened; the tooltip says how many pages that was. It doesn't mean the operator has no membership, because we don't read the whole website. no answer means the site blocked our check or never responded, so we read nothing there. Until 15 August 2026 the last two looked the same, and one guide said fifteen operators named no agency when one of them had never been read.

A website in German doesn't tell you that anyone on the boat speaks German.

What each Green Fins level means

The definitions below are quoted from the register.

A Certified Member "received an in-person assessment from a Green Fins assessor within the last 12 months" and is scored out of 330, where lower is better: Gold up to 50, Silver up to 150, Bronze up to 200.

A Digital Member self-evaluates, and "Digital Members do not have to pass a minimum requirement". The digital score runs on a separate scale to 10 and in the other direction, so the two scores cannot be compared. If every member at a location is Digital, nobody there has been assessed, and our page for that place says so in its title.

Restricted is not an administrative state. "Operations that score 201 or higher are classed as Restricted Members and will need to be reassessed to receive membership benefits", and a restricted member "has either not yet reached the minimum threshold assessment score, has not managed to effectively reduce their assessment score within the last two years or has been involved in an activity that is seen as seriously detrimental to the marine environment".

The register doesn't say which of the three applies to a given operation, and neither do we. We show the label but don't guess the reason.

What no register carries

Insurance. No public register of operator liability cover exists in the countries we cover, so anything said about it comes from the operator. Guide ratios and in-water practice. The Green Fins assessment covers environmental impact, not supervision. Instructor languages, where they are blank. A blank means no answer yet, not that nobody there speaks your language.

Which registers can be read lists which bodies publish a member list, which don't, and what each one returned. Nine of the twenty-six can be read, and four of the seventy-four lists here aren't based on any of them.

The whole directory as one file

Everything on these pages is also published as a single machine-readable file: directory-index.json. It has every place and every operator with its town, country, published languages and evidence level. It's rebuilt with the directory, so it always matches the pages.

You can use it to check our evidence in bulk instead of page by page. Use it, quote it, or compare it with your own data. If you build something with it, we'd like to hear about it.

Confirmed by the business

Every operator row ends in Is this you?, which opens our listing form with that entry filled in. If a business replies about its own entry and we can see the reply came from the business (for example, from an address at its own domain), the row is marked Confirmed with the date and how we knew. What the business tells us goes into the relevant fields, labelled claimed and dated like any other claim. A confirmation is the business speaking for itself, not an independent check, and a register entry still takes priority. A confirmed entry is listed first on its page for twelve months and may show the confirmed-listing badge. After that it drops back into place unless the business confirms again.

Corrections, and how to request one

If you run one of these businesses and a field is wrong, use Is this you? on its row, or email us the document. We'll correct it and date the correction. We don't remove a factual register entry just because someone asks; tell us why and we'll consider it. Listing and the badge are free. The only paid option is a business page: it puts a business at the top of its list for a year, marked Sponsored. Details are on the disclosure page.

Sources

  1. Green Fins membership definitions, quoted above. Certified membership and Digital membership, Reef-World Foundation with the UN Environment Programme, checked 2026-08-12.
  2. Our own register survey, twenty-six bodies, nine of them readable, on which registers can be read, each row dated.
← All places and operators